They're the best. My review I shared on Amazon last year: These toploaders are the highest quality I've ever seen! They are absolutely perfectly crystal clear compared to any others I've used, including Ultra-Pro's platinum toploaders. I had bought Ultra-Pro's platinums based on their claims that they are super clear, and they are clearer than their standard toploaders, but they are still noticeably blue-tinted and still hazy and show an undesirable glare in light. Pretty much any other toploader I've seen before has a bleuish tint which I'm not fond of. The Goat Armor toploaders have no tint at all and they feel very sturdy - as sturdy as the Ultra-Pro platinums. I've only unwrapped one of the 25-packs included in the 100-pack so far, but every single one looks perfect with no imperfections. I have absolutely no complaints and will be using these as my preference from now on. If you are about aesthetics and want the best quality toploader to view and appreciate your collection, look no further. These are so worth the money! Can't recommend them enough.
There is one negative point that I have to add as an update. I've noticed since that they seem to scratch VERY easily, even getting micro scratches just from sliding them into a plastic team bag or from sliding a hard sleeve into it. These usually aren't too visible or at all once the card is in there, but if you just use them without putting them inside a protector themselves, they WILL get scratched from flipping/shuffling through them. They seem to be safe in a toploader binder without extra protection (I haven't noticed scratches from that yet, but I don't take them in and out often).
I believe this might be an unavoidable trade-off for such clear plastic, but if it is possible to make them more scratch resistant, please do! It would make these absolutely god tier.
I also think it would be really good to produce them with protective films on both sides like some other toploaders and acrylic items do, to prevent scratching before they're even used. The packaging is very tight to keep them still and unscratched when the box is unopened, but once you get into it and start pulling some out to use them, they slide against each other and scratch each other.
